Client Focus: Board Members & Executives
Board Members
Current Environment
The Corporate environment is highly volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous.
This situation makes the Board of Directors role more important than ever.
The Board of Director’s role in the organization is to maintain impartial oversight of strategic decisions made by the organization’s executives on behalf of all stakeholders as well as coaching those executives to continue to grow their capabilities to reach their full career potential.
The Board should be the cornerstone upon which an organization builds its culture and allocates capital to create stakeholder value.
Boards of Directors are not operating as effectively as possible, as per PwC / Conference Board 2020 survey of executives and Board members, 49% of Board members believe one or more of their colleagues should be replaced.
Surprisingly, 82% of Company executives believe one or more Board members should be replaced.
Despite the lack of effectiveness, coaching of boards is fairly uncommon, with some directors reluctant to seek the support.
While significant business-oriented literature and popular press articles on corporate governance performance topics exist, there is a very limited number of comprehensive and rigorous studies that focus on the impact of coaching for individual Board members and for Boards as a team.
Why aren’t Boards performing effectively?
The ability to make ‘good’ decisions in the current environment is plagued with unproductive behaviors, including biases and blind-spots by individual Board members which leads to ineffective oversight by the Board as a team.
Board performance is a complex social system; effectiveness requires individual Board members to enhance their individual competencies and boardroom behaviors which lead to enhanced collaborative team dynamics.
Many Board members are not self-aware of how their behaviors impact the Board team as a whole; it is very awkward for a CEO or other Board member to confront a Board member to discuss disruptive behavior.
While significant investments have been made to enhance Board processes, including the Board feedback assessment process, this has not resulted in enough candid assessment to enhance individual and team performance
We have all experienced effective and ineffective Boards and have seen the “magic” of the best Boards, where individuals bring their best authentic selves to the board to build trust-based relationships; I believe this “magic” will happen more often when Board members have the appropriate coaching and feedback.
Approach and benefits to executive coaching for Boards
A: Individual Board members:
Work with the CEO and executive leadership team to focus on Board members that are new to the Board, new committee chairs, new lead directors and Board members that are not operating at their full potential.
Coaching relationship with individual Board members for a six-to-twelve-month engagement including ten to twenty sessions coaching the Board members, interviewing the CEO and key executives as well as other Board members to align on the issues to focus on (including biases and blind spots).
Board member to complete the Neethling Brain Instrument (NBI) thinking style assessment to understand their preferences to approaching issues and how this impacts their behaviors and effectiveness in their interactions with their Board colleagues and management .
Monitor and measure the progress that the Board member is making based on the new behaviors they are demonstrating in their Board role and measuring their progress to be more effective, based on discussions with the CEO, members of the executive team and other Board members.
Leverage the Columbia University coaching principles, process, capabilities and network.
The benefits would include: enhancing the quality of Board discussions, building the “speed of trust” amongst the Board members, more aligned and clear Board messaging to the CEO, more efficient and effective Board interactions, higher quality of Board self-assessment due to more open relationships, trust and less defensiveness, and being better prepared to deal with a crisis.
B: Teams of Board members: Committees and Full Board
Work with the CEO to identify the Board teams that would benefit from coaching (e.g., particular Board committee).
Work with the CEO and Committee chair or leader director to understand the “as is” of the team dynamics.
Interview the CEO and Board committee members to obtain feedback on opportunities to enhance effectiveness.
Observe teams in action to identify barriers for the team to behave more effectively; provide feedback to leaders and consider working with individual Board members, as appropriate (see above).
Executives
Current Environment
The Corporate environment has never been more highly volatile, uncertain, complex and ambiguous. Examples include:
Volatility is increasing due to economic trends including inflation, supply chain issues, federal reserve policy changes and labor disruptions.
Uncertainty is increasing due to geopolitical tension, covid virus evolution, new technologies like blockchain and new market entrants.
Complexity is increasing due to regulatory changes, the influence of social media, and political divisiveness.
Ambiguity is increasing as the “unknowns” complicate strategic planning, information overload, and need for increased experimentation and agility.
Approach and benefits to executive coaching
While consultants have worked with executives for over a century, the profession of coaching is still in the early stages of development, only about twenty years old. Therefore, it is not surprising that there is not a clear understanding of what value a coach delivers.
Given that the coaching industry is self regulated, I believe it is important for clients to consider the coaching partners they want to work with in a careful manner; especially the experience and technical training of a coach. Finding a coach with the experience, education and personality that creates a trust based relationship will result in the most value and benefit for a client.
In my work with clients, the first step is to conduct a “chemistry meeting” to ensure that the client-coach relationship will be mutually beneficial. I listen carefully to understand the hopes and concerns that clients have to deal with a challenge or opportunity.
I ask the client to complete a NBI thinking style assessment to enhance their ability to be self aware around how they approach relationships and situations to create a foundation for understanding their opportunity for growth and change. I collaborate with the client on situational analysis to identify the questions to consider and the data to gather so that we can clearly diagnose the situation.
I ask the client permission to obtain feedback from key stakeholders that they interact with and combine that with the feedback that the client is receiving in their day to day interactions. The client and I work together to explore potential options to consider; especially the costs and benefits of different approaches.
We then collaborate on creating a strategic plan and goals for the client to achieve their potential, while considering their personal values and the organizational priorities of their particular enterprise.
I then work closely with the client as they put their strategy into action, including balancing my support along with challenging the client, as appropriate, to achieve their goals. I help the client realistically assess their progress, including helping them maintain their focus on the day to day behaviors along with the big picture.
The International Coaching Federation defines coaching as “partnering with clients in a thought provoking and creative process that inspires them to maximize their personal and professional potential”. My coaching professor at Columbia used the following definition: “coaching is about moving valuable people from where they are to where they want to be”. He referred to coaching as the “science of human performance” which I think is an excellent description .
I believe, based on my experience, that working with a qualified coach can make a huge positive impact on reaching your professional and personal potential.
• • • • •
